Rihanna featuring Jay-Z: Umbrella
79/100
The baffling thing is why an album entitled Good Girl Gone Bad would kick off with such a tender pledge of loyalty and friendship. These lyrics aren’t just sweet, they’re actually virtuous. When’s the last time you could say that about a pop song?
Refreshing though they may be, however, its virtuous lyrics are not this song’s main virtue. As is—to put it mildly—common in the pop world, it’s the hook that made the song the overwhelming phenomenon it was and is, as this list will corroborate. It’s one of the best hooks in years. On my second listen through the song, I was already so determined to belt along with Rihanna full-voice in my car that I found it frustrating not to be able to memorize the chorus lyrics faster. This hook destroys brains. Add to that the incredible shine of the Dream/Stewart team’s synths, the winsome, unaffected sincerity of Rihanna’s delivery, and the masterstroke of having Jay-Z’s guest verse take the opening slot, and you’re on your way to a lasting winner of a hit. [I also appreciate the way the bassline subtly changes on the last choruses to reharmonize the prenominate amazing hook, unnecessary though it may be. I don't know why I so often respond favorably to excess.]
Seem like a low rating? Blame the bridge. It doesn’t go. First, that beat’s too good to drop out for that long. Second, it’s a suckerpunch when the crispy textures and dark, velvety melodies from the verses and choruses get unceremoniously and abruptly swapped for a gooey Lionel Richie detour. Piano and hand claps? Come on. That’s not this song. Third, the transition back to the chorus, as Rihanna goes to the leading tone, is the one trite melodic move in the entire track. Word to the wise: bridges generally arrive at a song’s dramatic peak, when stakes are highest. It really lets the air out of the song’s sails to fuck things up there.
That’s the only real chink; it just happens to be a sizable one. But hold the song up against the rest of the radio pabulum of last year (jeez, look at its competition for the Song of the Year Grammy!) and it shines like a diamond.
4:36. FROM THE ALBUM GOOD GIRL GONE BAD. P: THE-DREAM, TRICKY STEWART. W: TERIUS “THE DREAM” NASH, CHRISTOPHER STEWART, AND JAY-Z. US RELEASE: MARCH 29, 2007. DEF JAM RECORDS.